The Caledonia Public Square Memories & Futures Project is a new oral history & arts activation project designed & carried out by oral historian, sound recordist, & community arts organizer Jess Lamar Reece Holler (Caledonia Northern Folk Studios) for the Village of Caledonia (Marion County, Ohio), supported through an Ohio Arts Council Arts Resiliency Initiative Community Project Grant for COVID-19 economic recovery.
The project focuses on the unique history of Caledonia, Ohio’s Public Square — a monumental open square comprised of Village Hall, the Union Block Building, the Underwood Building, the “Class of ‘55” Building, & the Temple & Masonic Blocks. Built as a boosterist project by Mayor J. Blanchard & a coalition of downtown merchants, business-owners, professionals, & their fraternal organizations, Caledonia’s Public Square rose to prominence during the height of the railroad era (1890s), when Caledonia became a major railway hub & stop-over location between Marion & Galion. The Square was also conveniently located along the route of Highway 30: then known as the “Lincoln Highway.”
Caledonia became a frequent stop for travelers — both by train & by automobile — who stayed over at the three-story Hanley House on Water Street, dined in Caledonia restaurants & pubs, & worshipped in Caledonia’s network of churches. And, at home, the Square became a regional destination for farmers & others from the network of smaller rural villages & unincorporated communities surrounding Caledonia: along the borders of Marion, Morrow, & Crawford Counties. Additionally, its reputation as an “organization town” — a hotbed of fraternal organization activity, with the Oliver Lodge #447 of the F&A Masons, Knights of Pythias Order of Calanthe #116, International Order of Oddfellows, & Women’s Auxiliaries of all three (Eastern Star; Lady Pythians; Sisters of Rebekah). Caledonia’s American Legion Post #401 provided a similar mutual aid service for area veterans & their descendents or family.
By the 20th century, the Public Square had become the site of many time-honored community traditions: from “medicine shows” & vaudeville acts above Village Hall in the 1920s to the American Legion Post #401’s Decoration Day procession to “Movies on the Square” (projected onto Garber Sisters’ groceries by a traveling projectionist) in the 1940s-1950s to the hustle & bustle of activities surrounding Caledonia’s centennial (1974) & America’s Bicentennial (1976), which lit a new craze for local history, downtown revitalization, & placekeeping in our small community. These spirits eventually led to a height of festival activity on the Square: the Firemans’ Festival of the 1960s, & the Farmers’ Festival that brought an entire carnival, bier garten, & midway experience right to the Public Square from the 1970s thru early 1990s.
Fates changed for the Public Square by the late 1990s, when competition from monopoly big-box stores, increased mobility, & a newly atomized culture threatened collective life, commerce, & leisure on the Square. The 1990s-2010s saw the shuttering of many long-time Caledonia businesses — including Sickel’s IGA, May’s Hardware, Reece’s Market, Carol Ault’s Dance Factory, the Caledonia Branch library, & the bank — & a rise in majority vacancy for Public Square storefronts & buildings.
The 2020’s, however, are showing stirrings of investment in downtown revitalization — including through connecting with & resurfacing our community’s rich history, multi-ethnic heritages, & traditions. In 2021, the Temple & Masonic Block Buildings became the first downtown commercial storefront buildings in any Marion County Village to be listed to the National Register of Historic Places. Moreover, in Summer 2021, Mayor April Morrison founded the Caledonia Farmers’ Market — a weekly strategy to get people out on the Public Square — which became its own 501(c)(3) in 2022. Following on the heels of the market, another non-profit — Friends of Caledonia — was also established in 2020 (incorporated in 2022) to help bring back community festivals on the Square: including through a downtown Hallowe’en celebration for young people (& the young-at-heart), “Christmas on the Square,” & plans to bring back the Farmers’ Festival. Moreover, in 2022, the Masonic Block Building was selected for a $58,000 rehabilitation investment by the Marion County Commisioners’ FY2023 Community Development Block Grant; & the Village of Caledonia put forward a Pipeline Grant to prepare a National Register of Historic Places historic district nomination for the related Public Square & Water Street commercial corridors.
Both historic preservation & cultural heritage organizing are a key part of these efforts to re-connect community life on the Square, as a way to dream forward more abundant futures. The Caledonia Public Square Memories & Futures Project joins these efforts here as an arts-& oral history-based activation tool: mobilizing memories of the Square to gather diverse community member dreams forward for adaptive reuse of the Square, & with it, civic & community life in Caledonia.
The project commenced in January & February 2022 with a series of four community planning meetings: spaces for Caledonia residents to share memories of the Public Square & hopes for its future, & to recommend a long-list (& vote on a shortlist) of potential narrators (interviewees) for the project; & then conducted ten full-length oral history interviews with Caledonia residents (past & present) with significant residential, commercial, cultural, organizational, or leadership roles on the Public Square. Those interviews were each extensively edited into “first person” audio documentaries — in the voice of each narrator, with the oral history dialogue removed; & five aggregate media documentaries were created to highlight overarching themes in the history, traditions, & significance of the Public Square.
LISTEN HERE: caledonianorthern.org/oral-history
Please enjoy the project — & may these memories help spur you to imagine your role in a revitalized Public Square!
Thank you to all community co-curators, project planners, & narrators: for your time, your insights, & your trust. The Caledonia Public Square Memories & Futures Project was made possible in part thanks to an Arts Resiliency Initiative Community Project Grant from the Ohio Arts Council. We are grateful to OAC for this transformative support, which has made this project possible.